Reading the seminal Preservation case of Penn Central Transportation Co. v. City of New York, I find it ironic that in 1978 the Supreme Court upheld the validity of the Landmark designation, process and protection, contending that Penn Central was being whiney in demanding that they couldn’t build a big new Breuer tower directly over Grand Central Terminal. Penn Central Co. claimed they were being cheated out of the maximum profit, the court ruled, among other things, that while they had a constitutional right to make a “reasonable rate of return” no one in fact had the constitutional right to “the highest and best use” of your property. There’s a lot more in here, but what is ironic, is that, just as the court ruled back then (the terminal was making a reasonable return as it existed) today Grand Central, as it grows more and more commercialized—I’m especially thinking of the Apple Store here—the terminal is making very fine use of it’s profitability within the constraints provided. See? they did just fine.
September 11, 2012
“highest and best use”
This entry was posted on Tuesday, September 11th, 2012 at 17:02 and tagged with nyc, on preservation and posted in historic pres. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.
adventures of a new Georgia resident, a long time coming
- adventure arabia mountain art atl atlanta beltline bike buckhead cartersville cemetery church city cooking dekalb demolition development downtown east atlanta eav energy efficiency explore food garden georgia georgia trust graffiti historic pres historic pres technology history houses industrial lithonia lost lost city marietta marta midtown modern museum neighborhood new construction news nyc old house preservation quarry railroad ranch recent past rehab resources and research restoration reynoldstown rhodes hall rockmart rome rural senoia small town sparta stone mountain streetcar streetfood suburbia technical trains turkey urban urban decay urban exploration urban planning west end westside winter weather wrens nest